When Debate becomes Argument ( by Carley Evans )

“Let me see you celebrate this,” says Michael Douglas as the U.S. President in the movie — oh my, I actually can not retrieve the title. Anyway, he stands at a podium before the seal of the presidency and says we should celebrate the freedom we have in this country to yes — burn the flag, protest abortion, lobby for gay rights, support our troops, vote in the next election. [Oh, the movie is THE AMERICAN PRESIDENT!]

We should defend the right for our sworn enemy to shout at the top of his lungs in protest of something we’d shout at the top of our lungs to support. Michael Douglas as the president says something close to this — always stand up for freedom of expression! Stand up for the right of people you do not admire or believe are correct to speak their minds.

Our right to speak our minds is extraordinarily rare in the greater world.

The problem comes when debate becomes strife. They say this; we say that. They say it again in a slightly different manner perhaps even contradicting a previous statement. We point that out; they ignore the facts. They continue their line of thinking; we continue ours. And then, one of the two sides starts to get annoyed. Emotion steps in. Debate becomes argument.

That this is the nature of disagreement is not surprising. When you hold a belief as the absolute truth, then the difficulty is in not expressing it with urgency. How do you do that? How do you tell someone they are flat out wrong without that overwhelming sense of urgency? If you care about those people or about the truth, then emotion likely plays a role.

God says to “speak the truth in love.”

Father God, help me to always remember to gently speak Your truths. In Jesus’ Name, amen.


6 thoughts on “When Debate becomes Argument ( by Carley Evans )

  1. lambskinny says:

    Thanks, bwinwnbwi.

  2. lambskinny says:

    Thank you Leroy. I appreciate your readership! God bless, Carley

  3. lambskinny says:

    Thank you so much, Patricia.

  4. mtsweat says:

    Yes, may we always speak the truth in love. Unfortunately, we sometimes prove what we believe to be absolute truths by our actions and reactions. God bless Carley.

    • lambskinny says:

      Yep, that’s pretty convicting. I have to agree. I tend to be a very intense person — I desire to use what I consider commonsense and logic to convince others of why they are in error while at the same time really listening to their point of view. So often semantics seem to be the major difference between Christians. It is like we are all talking about the same thing but we refuse to see it — it is like we want to argue with each other! Don’t fully understand it.

      Christians should be united, period.

      And so, I stand corrected. Please forgive me.
      Thanks, M.T.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s